Ask Mr. Smarty Plants is a free service provided by the staff and volunteers at the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center.
Can't find the answer in our existing FAQs, submit a question to Mr. Smarty Plants.
Need help with plant identification, visit the plant identification page.
From: Kingsland, TX
Region: Southwest
Topic: Container Gardens, Compost and Mulch, Transplants, Trees
Title: Holding an Acer rubrum in a container for two years
Answered by: Barbara Medford
From our Native Plant Database on Acer rubrum (red maple):
"Very tolerant of soils, however, prefers slighly acid, moist condition; tolerant of ozone and intermediately tolerant of sulphur dioxide. Not particulary urban tolerant, although planted in ever-increasing numbers in cities."
The red maple is native to both Virginia and Texas, but more so to East Texas, with its moist acidic soil than West Texas, with alkaline, rocky, often dry soils. Frankly, our first impulse is to discourage keeping a tree in a container for up to two years. One of the biggest problems with trees that are purchased from commercial nurseries is that they have been in containers too long and become rootbound.
We went to a website, Gardening Know How, Growing Trees in Containers, to try and get some ideas on just how difficult it might be, understanding that you are anxious to preserve a heritage tree. It would appear, from this article, that it is doable, provided it is shipped properly and in a timely manner and arrives in a robust condition. Since it sounds as though the tree won't be much more than a seedling at the time of purchase, hopefully the roots will not yet have been affected by container size. We would certainly recommend that you immediately move it into a much larger pot, with good drainage, and one you believe will be roomy enough for two years' root growth. Since its pretty small and with not very well developed roots, you are probably going to need to give it some support to make sure it grows up straight and tall. Every time it is repotted or moved, it is going to experience a great deal of stress. It is going to have to be monitored for soil moisture, as any plant in a pot will dry out more quickly. It will also need to be protected from severe heat and cold, for the same reason. Roots in the dirt are insulated by the whole Earth, roots in a pot have only a little dirt and some plastic insulating them. We would query the vendor on how it will be shipped, whether in a pot with appropriate soil or perhaps bare-root? If bare-root, how long has it been out of the ground before it is shipped? Is there an "arrive alive" guarantee? If you give it the thumbnail test, scratching the bark with your thumbnail, and there is no green layer beneath the bark, it didn't arrive alive.
Assuming that everything works, and the little tree is thriving when you get ready to plant it in the ground at your new property, more preparation is important. Remember, when selecting the site, that maples tend to have surface roots that can be invasive and disruptive of paving, driveways, even foundations. Place it accordingly, even if you think it will be 20 years before it becomes a problem. As you will note in the quotation from our database, this tree is tolerant of soils, so it should be able to adjust to the more alkaline soil in West Texas. Nevertheless, it wouldn't hurt to begin preparing the site where you wish to plant the tree ahead of time by amending the soil. Some good organic compost will always help in adjusting soil Ph, and certainly will improve drainage and the ability of the roots to take up trace minerals needed for flourishing. Transplanting in cool weather, when the tree is near dormant, is also a good idea. It should be watered by thrusting a hose down in the soil, letting it drip slowly until water appears on the surface, and repeating two or three times a week, more often in hot weather.
So, to answer your question, yes, we think you can do it, but be prepared to spend considerable time keeping the tree not only alive but healthy, so it can grace your new garden for a long time to come.
Different kinds of plants living in subarctic areas
March 10, 2008 - What are the different kinds of plants live in the subarctic areas?
view the full question and answer
Pruning an oak tree in Missouri in February
February 09, 2009 - Can I prune an oak tree in Missouri in February?
view the full question and answer
Pecan tree dropping limbs in Grand Prairie, TX.
September 04, 2012 - Our 15 year old pecan tree is losing it's limbs. The tree and its leaves look healthy with no signs of bugs or mites, but all the limbs are drooping and breaking off. The tree did have a bumper crop ...
view the full question and answer
Non-native Boulevard Cypress Pom Pom trees in Princeton NJ
October 29, 2011 - I just had some landscaping done near my front door and front yard. I have two Boulevard Cypress B&B (4-5') Pom Pom. The pom poms are turning brown. What should I have been doing? I am watering them ...
view the full question and answer
Native plants of Taos and Los Alamos NM from Houston
April 07, 2012 - Hi, Mr. Smarty Plants, can you recommend a guidebook for the native plants of the Taos/Los Alamos region? (I'm most interested in forbs.) I'll be headed there in May--is there anything I should es...
view the full question and answer
![]() |
Support the Wildflower Center by Donating Online or Becoming a Member today. Mr. Smarty Plants wants you to be his Facebook friend. Click the Facebook icon to add yourself to Mr. Smarty Plants list of friends. |